Agenda item
Planning:
a. To note that Councillor Lennox-Boyd will vote upon the information before her at the meeting but in the light of subsequent information received at Cornwall Council, Councillor Lennox-Boyd may vote differently at that meeting.
b. To note that if Councillor Lennox-Boyd wishes to recommend opposite to the Town Council’s view she will contact the Town Council by email. Considering time constraints, the Town Council will then hold an online poll of Councillors to determine whether to accept the Officer’s view or to ask for the application to be called into committee. The results of these polls will be read into the record at the next Town Council meeting. Members of the public may request, via the Clerk, to be copied into any correspondence.
c. Applications for consideration:
PA22/01691
Mr Roger Legg R.A. and M. Legg and Sons – Ricksdale Cottages Road from Liskeard Road To Castle Hill Trematon Cornwall PL12 4RT
Construction of a storage shed and creation of access track.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 23/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/02259
Mr Andrew Stafford – Land West Of Rickdale Cottages Trematon Cornwall PL12 4RT
Proposed change of land usage, from Agricultural to occasional leisure use for the purpose of combat gaming activities (Laser Tag and Airsoft gaming).
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 28/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA21/11848
Mr & Mrs Kearney - 1 Chapman Court Latchbrook PL12 4TT
First floor front extension and two storey rear extension.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 20/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/02228
Mrs Ruth Stott – 12 Convent Close Saltash Cornwall PL12 6HA
Two storey side extension for additional family accommodation.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 17/03/22
Response date: 28/04/22
PA22/02279
Mr & Mrs Mike Leggett, Mike Leggett Building Plans Ltd – 35 St Georges Road Saltash PL12 6EH
Removal of existing dormers, formation of hips to gables and formation of front and rear dormers.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 10/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/02331
N/A Greggs PLC – 1 Channon Road Saltash PL12 6LX
One Fascia Sign and One Totem Sign
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 04/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/02333
Greggs PLC – Cloud Break Surf Moorlands Trading Estate Callington Road Saltash PL12 6LX
External alterations to the building including plant, new bin store, car park alterations and associated works.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 30/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/02643
Mr D Watson – 41 Clear View Saltash PL12 6HD
Two-storey side extension.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 31/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/02762
Mr Wayne Greenidge – 31 Dartmoor View Saltash PL12 6WF
Two storey extension to rear elevation to form enlarged lounge, kitchen and dining room on ground floor and extended bedrooms on first floor.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 08/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/03007
Mr & Mrs James – Spindrift Westbourne Terrace Saltash PL12 6BX
Proposed extension to rear dormer including external balcony.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 31/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/03049
Mrs A & Mr L Rangelov – 14 Hillside Avenue Saltash PL12 6HF
Alterations to roof to allow for rooms in roof with a rear dormer.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 11/04/22
Response date: 02/05/22
PA22/03097
Mr Tim Atkinson – Eales Barn Carkeel Saltash PL12 6NR
Proposed extension to existing barn. New terraced swimming pool and garden within existing garden area.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 13/04/22
Response date: 04/05/22
PA22/03099
Mr & Mrs D Harrison – 2 Mote Park Saltash PL12 4JX
Single-storey front extension to provide entrance porch.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 05/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/03136
Mr D I Barrett Tamar Fresh Ltd – Land At Pillmere Drive Saltash
Change of use of part of existing B8 warehouse building to use as fish and chip shop A5 hot food and take away.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 07/04/22.
Response date: 28/04/22.
PA22/03144
Ms Elizabeth Gay – 8 & 10 Hillside Road Saltash PL12 6EX
Loft conversions with new dormer windows to the front elevation of both halves of adjacent semi-detached bungalows.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 07/04/22
Response date: 28/04/22
PA22/03148
Mr Peter Gain – Ince Castle Road From Elmgate Crossways To Greeps Elmgate Saltash PL12 4QZ
Proposed Oak garden profiled balustrade, partially completed. With proposed dwarf local stone wall.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 06/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/03153
Peter Gain – Ince Castle Road From Elmgate Crossways To Greeps Elmgate Saltash PL12 4QZ
Erection of 2no. south garden Pavilions
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 06/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
PA22/03178
Mr Peter Gain - Ince Castle Road From Elmgate Crossways To Greeps Elmgate Saltash
New growing garden layout and erection of new units – Main Glasshouse, Fruitcage, cold frames, garden walls, storage sheds, potting shed, Tennis Pavilion & existing Pool House refurbishment.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 11/04/22
Response date: 02/05/22
PA22/03612
Mr & Mrs Kawolski – 341 New Road Saltash PL12 6HL
Proposed garage/retaining wall and steps to provide off street parking. New floor area 17.5 s.q.m.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 19/04/22
Response date: 10/05/22
d. Tree Applications:
PA22/02959
Mr Matt Underwoo – Land South of 6 Carkeel Barns Carkeel Cornwall PL12 6PR
Application for tree works within TPO: A reduction of all lateral growth by 1m on the eastern side of the tree (G8) nearest the building.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 04/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
Minutes:
a. To note that Councillor Lennox-Boyd will vote upon the information before her at the meeting but in the light of subsequent information received at Cornwall Council, Councillor Lennox-Boyd may vote differently at that meeting.
b. To note that if Councillor Lennox-Boyd wishes to recommend opposite to the Town Council’s view she will contact the Town Council by email. Considering time constraints, the Town Council will then hold an online poll of Councillors to determine whether to accept the Officer’s view or to ask for the application to be called into committee. The results of these polls will be read into the record at the next Town Council meeting. Members of the public may request, via the Clerk, to be copied into any correspondence.
c. Applications for consideration:
Councillor Lennox-Boyd declared an interest in the next two agenda items and left the meeting.
After a discussion with the member of the public wishing to speak in objection to PA22/01691 and PA22/02259, the Chairman announced that PA22/02259 would be the first Planning Application to be considered under Agenda Item No. 7c to be followed by PA22/01691.
PA22/02259
Mr Andrew Stafford – Land West Of Rickdale Cottages Trematon Cornwall PL12 4RT
Proposed change of land usage, from Agricultural to occasional leisure use for the purpose of combat gaming activities (Laser Tag and Airsoft gaming).
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 28/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
A member of the public spoke in objection to PA22/02259.
It was proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Stoyel and resolved to RECOMMEND REFUSAL on the grounds of:
1. Unsuitable location for gaming activities due to being in an area of outstanding natural beauty.
2. Proposed site too close to neighbouring dwellings resulting in noise and disturbance.
3. Highway issues, in particular traffic generation, vehicular access and highway safety.
4. Reference in the proposal to ‘occasional leisure use’ is unspecific.
PA22/01691
Mr Roger Legg R.A. and M. Legg and Sons – Ricksdale Cottages Road from Liskeard Road To Castle Hill Trematon Cornwall PL12 4RT
Construction of a storage shed and creation of access track.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 23/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
A member of the public spoke for three minutes in objection to PA22/01691.
It was proposed by Councillor Stoyel, seconded by Councillor Foster and resolved to RECOMMEND REFUSAL on the grounds of:
1. The shed is situated in the wrong place and should be nearer to the access point.
2. A replacement road is not required due to the prior existence of a useful track.
3. The siting of the shed and the proposed lengthy hard track neither enhance nor conserve the existing character of the site to the detriment of the wider AONB landscape within this location.
Councillor Lennox-Boyd was invited and returned to the meeting.
The Chairman announced that PA22/03097 would be the next Planning Application to be considered under Agenda Item No. 7c.
Councillor Lennox-Boyd declared an interest in the next agenda item and left the meeting.
PA22/03097
Mr Tim Atkinson – Eales Barn Carkeel Saltash PL12 6NR
Proposed extension to existing barn. New terraced swimming pool and garden within existing garden area.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 13/04/22
Response date: 04/05/22
A member of the public spoke in objection to PA22/03097.
It was proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Martin and resolved to RECOMMEND REFUSAL on the grounds of:
1. The previous planning response from Saltash Town Council to PA21/03391 dated 23rd July 2021 states that ‘It was resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL subject to the condition that no boundary walls are removed and that this area cannot be used for future development. No development whatsoever is to be built on this land’.
2. Cornwall Council’s Grant of Conditional Planning Permission PA21/03391 dated 22nd December 2021 supported the above response within the conditions of that Planning Permission.
3. The applicant is now requesting planning permission via PA22/03097 for a proposal which has already been refused via Cornwall Council’s Grant of Conditional Planning Permission PA21/03391.
Councillor Lennox-Boyd was invited and returned to the meeting.
PA21/11848
Mr & Mrs Kearney - 1 Chapman Court Latchbrook PL12 4TT
First floor front extension and two storey rear extension.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 20/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Martin and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/02228
Mrs Ruth Stott – 12 Convent Close Saltash Cornwall PL12 6HA
Two storey side extension for additional family accommodation.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 17/03/22
Response date: 28/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Foster, seconded by Councillor Bullock and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/02279
Mr & Mrs Mike Leggett, Mike Leggett Building Plans Ltd – 35 St Georges Road Saltash PL12 6EH
Removal of existing dormers, formation of hips to gables and formation of front and rear dormers.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 10/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Foster, seconded by Councillor Stoyel and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/02331
N/A Greggs PLC – 1 Channon Road Saltash PL12 6LX
One Fascia Sign and One Totem Sign
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 04/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Bullock, seconded by Councillor Foster and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/02333
Greggs PLC – Cloud Break Surf Moorlands Trading Estate Callington Road Saltash PL12 6LX
External alterations to the building including plant, new bin store, car park alterations and associated works.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 30/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Foster, seconded by Councillor Lennox-Boyd and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/02643
Mr D Watson – 41 Clear View Saltash PL12 6HD
Two-storey side extension.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 31/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Martin, seconded by Councillor Gillies and resolved to RECOMMEND REFUSAL due to:
1. Absence of sufficient information.
2. Overdevelopment of the site and lack of amenity space.
3. Overlooking of neighbouring property.
4. Not compatible with the ground layout.
5. Potential for construction issues.
6. Lack of amenity space.
PA22/02762
Mr Wayne Greenidge – 31 Dartmoor View Saltash PL12 6WF
Two storey extension to rear elevation to form enlarged lounge, kitchen and dining room on ground floor and extended bedrooms on first floor.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 08/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Bullock, seconded by Councillor Stoyel and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/03007
Mr & Mrs James – Spindrift Westbourne Terrace Saltash PL12 6BX
Proposed extension to rear dormer including external balcony.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 31/03/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Stoyel, seconded by Councillor Lennox-Boyd and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/03049
Mrs A & Mr L Rangelov – 14 Hillside Avenue Saltash PL12 6HF
Alterations to roof to allow for rooms in roof with a rear dormer.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 11/04/22
Response date: 02/05/22
It was proposed by Councillor Martin, seconded by Councillor Lennox-Boyd and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/03099
Mr & Mrs D Harrison – 2 Mote Park Saltash PL12 4JX
Single-storey front extension to provide entrance porch.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 05/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Foster, seconded by Councillor Gillies and resolved to RECOMMEND REFUSAL on the grounds of:
1. The proposal is too large for the site.
2. Overdevelopment of the site.
3. Out of character with the site.
4. Wrong side of the building line.
Councillor Gillies declared an interest in the next agenda item and left the meeting.
The Chairman announced a 2 minute break at 20:08
The Chairman reconvened the meeting at 20:10
PA22/03136
Mr D I Barrett Tamar Fresh Ltd – Land At Pillmere Drive Saltash
Change of use of part of existing B8 warehouse building to use as fish and chip shop A5 hot food and take away.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 07/04/22.
Response date: 28/04/22.
It was proposed by Councillor Foster, seconded by Councillor Stoyel and resolved to RECOMMEND REFUSAL on the grounds of:
1. Highway issues, including traffic generation, vehicular access, highway safety;
2. Particularly parking for customers and allocation for staff parking.
Councillor Gillies was invited and returned to the meeting.
PA22/03144
Ms Elizabeth Gay – 8 & 10 Hillside Road Saltash PL12 6EX
Loft conversions with new dormer windows to the front elevation of both halves of adjacent semi-detached bungalows.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 07/04/22
Response date: 28/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Lennox-Boyd and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
Councillor Lennox-Boyd declared an interest in the next three agenda items and left the meeting.
PA22/03148
Mr Peter Gain – Ince Castle Road From Elmgate Crossways To Greeps Elmgate Saltash PL12 4QZ
Proposed Oak garden profiled balustrade, partially completed. With proposed dwarf local stone wall.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 06/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Miller, seconded by Councillor Stoyel and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/03153
Peter Gain – Ince Castle Road From Elmgate Crossways To Greeps Elmgate Saltash PL12 4QZ
Erection of 2no. south garden Pavilions
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 06/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
It was proposed by Councillor Stoyel, seconded by Councillor Foster and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
PA22/03178
Mr Peter Gain - Ince Castle Road From Elmgate Crossways To Greeps Elmgate Saltash
New growing garden layout and erection of new units – Main Glasshouse, Fruitcage, cold frames, garden walls, storage sheds, potting shed, Tennis Pavilion & existing Pool House refurbishment.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 11/04/22
Response date: 02/05/22
It was proposed by Councillor Stoyel, seconded by Councillor Miller and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
Councillor Lennox-Boyd was invited and returned to the meeting.
PA22/03612
Mr & Mrs Kawolski – 341 New Road Saltash PL12 6HL
Proposed garage/retaining wall and steps to provide off street parking. New floor area 17.5 s.q.m.
Ward: Tamar
Date received: 19/04/22
Response date: 10/05/22
It was proposed by Councillor Foster, seconded by Councillor Stoyel and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL
d. Tree applications:
PA22/02959
Mr Matt Underwoo – Land South of 6 Carkeel Barns Carkeel Cornwall PL12 6PR
Application for tree works within TPO: A reduction of all lateral growth by 1m on the eastern side of the tree (G8) nearest the building.
Ward: Trematon
Date received: 04/04/22
Response date: 29/04/22
The Chairman informed Members of the Cornwall Council Tree Officer’s Report.
It was proposed by Councillor Gillies, seconded by Councillor Foster and resolved to RECOMMEND APPROVAL in line with the Cornwall Council Tree Officer’s Report and subject to the Cornwall Council Tree Officer keeping this work under review.